Almost every week LB and I go to Toddler Story Time at the library. He loves it. The librarian that usually leads it is a celebrity at our house. LB and I were in the kids area at the library the other day and that particular librarian started walking towards us and LB pointed and gasped. It was pretty hilarious. There was a time frame when LB was 15 months - 22 months in age and story time was often a bit of a struggle. I wondered why I brought him when all he wanted to do was play with the door handles (perhaps he wanted to escape) and grab stuff off the librarian's table. There was the time he started the music before I could catch him and then I couldn't figure out how to turn it off. That was embarrassing. But now that he is a bit older he really gets into it and will listen to the books and loves the interactive singing. He will almost always behave if he knows he will get a stamp and a sticker at the end. The librarian is popular with the kids for good reason. He does a great job of mixing up songs, books and storytelling with the felt board.
The librarian usually has a theme for each week. Last week it was cats and the week before that it was the alphabet. Several weeks ago it was the "Are You My Mother" theme. Are you familiar with the book? I used to think it was really cute. Basically, there is a little bird that can't find his mother. He goes up to all sorts of other animals like a dog and a cow, who clearly don't look like him, and asks, "Are you my mother?" Finally, the little bird finds the mama bird and all is well. For most of the story time the librarian talked about different animals and read books about animals, which is understandably a crowd favorite. However, at one point the librarian put a little baby alligator up on the felt board and told the kids that the baby alligator was looking for his mother. Then he put an elephant on the board and asked if that was his mother and then a lion and so on and so on. Finally, he put a bigger alligator on the felt board and asked the kids if the baby found his mother. To make his point that the baby alligator had achieved success he said, "This must be his mother because they are both green." That was when I really cringed and honestly felt very sad. Perhaps I was being oversensitive. LB wasn't really paying attention at that point and if he were I am not sure he would have understood. But he does know that he is brown and I am white. He has gotten quite good at identifying his colors. I suppose the whole theme just felt a little outdated. I started to think about friends that are in interracial relationships and have biological children that aren't the exact same color as them or families with two dads. I do know that we are different and our story is not always going to fit the mold and I am okay with that. But I couldn't help feeling sad for LB that even in the places you don't expect it your differences will be pointed out to you. As the story time went on, I worked up the courage to say something. My plan was to be polite, appreciative and just try to suggest that it was outdated. But by the time the librarian was done passing out stickers, LB had bolted out of the room and was running loose through the computer lab. I have since lost my courage. What do you think? Should I say something or let it go?
The librarian usually has a theme for each week. Last week it was cats and the week before that it was the alphabet. Several weeks ago it was the "Are You My Mother" theme. Are you familiar with the book? I used to think it was really cute. Basically, there is a little bird that can't find his mother. He goes up to all sorts of other animals like a dog and a cow, who clearly don't look like him, and asks, "Are you my mother?" Finally, the little bird finds the mama bird and all is well. For most of the story time the librarian talked about different animals and read books about animals, which is understandably a crowd favorite. However, at one point the librarian put a little baby alligator up on the felt board and told the kids that the baby alligator was looking for his mother. Then he put an elephant on the board and asked if that was his mother and then a lion and so on and so on. Finally, he put a bigger alligator on the felt board and asked the kids if the baby found his mother. To make his point that the baby alligator had achieved success he said, "This must be his mother because they are both green." That was when I really cringed and honestly felt very sad. Perhaps I was being oversensitive. LB wasn't really paying attention at that point and if he were I am not sure he would have understood. But he does know that he is brown and I am white. He has gotten quite good at identifying his colors. I suppose the whole theme just felt a little outdated. I started to think about friends that are in interracial relationships and have biological children that aren't the exact same color as them or families with two dads. I do know that we are different and our story is not always going to fit the mold and I am okay with that. But I couldn't help feeling sad for LB that even in the places you don't expect it your differences will be pointed out to you. As the story time went on, I worked up the courage to say something. My plan was to be polite, appreciative and just try to suggest that it was outdated. But by the time the librarian was done passing out stickers, LB had bolted out of the room and was running loose through the computer lab. I have since lost my courage. What do you think? Should I say something or let it go?
Oh I really think you should say something!!! In a nice way, I mean. I am certain this librarian didn't mean anything by his story and he probably never thought about it. This is a chance for you to be an advocate and provide some education. They could read Mother for Choco instead! And there are lots of animals in nature who don't look like their mothers (Swans, for example). Let us know what you decide to do. I would have had the same reaction you did!
ReplyDeleteHave you read Mother for Choco? It's a childrens book on adoption that's all animals. (one of our favs!)It's pretty much the opposite story. If I were you, I'd buy it for the library if they don't have it yet? Maybe that could be your conversation starter with the librarian?
ReplyDeleteI totally think you should say something. I love Katie's idea of donating a book to the library that addresses the issue appropriately. Then you can include a note with it, so you don't have to feel confrontational.
ReplyDeleteAnd for the record, I never liked that book. As a kid, it seemed scary to me that the baby bird had lost his mom and resorted to asking large pieces of machinery if they might be its mother. Your mom is the one who loves you and is there for you, not the one who looks just like you do.
I'd say something. And I was also going to suggest a Mother for Choco. Same exact theme, except that the mother ended up being a bear to the bird. That theme is so outdated. Neither of my children, whether adopted or not look like me. That doesn't mean I'm less of a mama to them. Sorry Emily!
ReplyDeleteI'm kind of shocked that he was so oblivious. Why wouldn't he just say "because they're both alligators"? That they're both green doesn't even make sense. Turtles, snakes, bugs are all green, too!
ReplyDeleteAnd I'm with everyone else. I think you should say something, kindly of course, about how disappointed you were that he used color as the reason they belong to each other. (I mean really, think about how many families that DOESN'T work for, with both adopted and biological kids!)
love the ideas and comments. say something for sure. easy for me to say, though, as I could use some courage myself sometimes :-)
ReplyDeleteI would say something but if it was me.. I probably would ramble and not make any sense. I write much better than I can speak when I want to express my anger or frustration.
ReplyDeleteI would say something too. And I like the idea of suggesting the book "A Mother for Choco".
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think everyone has had great advice. I also think that you could begin your conservation or your letter with some of the compliments to this librarian that you included in this post--how he is practically a celebrity to LB, how he does a great job engaging the kids in different ways, etc. He might be more receptive if you first point out how much you value his work.
ReplyDeleteAnd I think that the value of his work is exactly why you should say something. This is not a random person at an airport who asks inappropriate questions-- this is someone whose work has the potential to reach hundreds of kids and families. This is an awkward situation that is worth having, because this person is in a position to educate so many others.
I also agree with Brooke that it's totally creepy when the bird asks construction machinery if it's his mother. Get some sense, little bird!
I would definitely approach the librarian. I think the idea of donating a more appropriate book would be great too. So many children don't look the same as their parents- for a bunch of reasons- adoption, interracial parents, kids of gay parents, kids with legal guardians, kids with single parents, etc....LOTS of constantly read "classics" need to be updated and replaced with a more diverse group of books reflecting all sorts of lives. Definitely say something, my little unsung hero :)
ReplyDeleteP.S. our story time librarian is like a HUGE rock star around here too. Hilarious
It is sort of surprising that he (and I'm sure others) didn't think anything of having that conversation with a transracial child/mother in the audience. But this man sounds like a good, thoughtful man, and I bet he would actually appreciate being thoughtfully approached so that he can learn. I love the idea of suggesting another book. Little Miss Spider is another one that would be along the same theme but with the opposite outcome! Good luck.
ReplyDelete